Welcome to our course blog. I invite you to post developed, organized, thoughtful responses to the texts we read. It would be impossible to explore every one of our texts completely, so here we'll continue class discussion, introducing and/or developing perspectives. I want you to write and to read what others have written, and I encourage you to respond to each other. Disagreement is fine, so long as disagreement centers on the text and is respectful.
Thursday, February 23, 2012
First Thoughts
When I first started reading Annie on My Mind I was not truly impressed. I felt as though it was slow and a little boring. This stuck with me until I reached about the 4th or 5th chapter, then in my mind I slowly began to change Liza's character to that of a boy. Then it became more interesting and I started to develop the character a little more through the eye's of a male. It does seem to be an easy idea to adapt to but when Liza and Annie are together she seems to fall into the male role quite easily. For example, when the girl's are in the muesum Liza describes Annie as being a fair madien or even the "unicorn", but Liza does not get any feminim titles. The thing that really pushed me over the edge that determinded in my mind was when Liza went over to Annie's house for the first time. First, Liza bought Annie a gift/present. Right here this sent a red flag to me, this is Liza courting Annie, she may unconciously being thinking she is courting her but its evident that she it. Second, Liza has so much build up in going to Annie's house. Reading it made me think back to old movies that talk about how nervous boys are going over to a girl's house, for a date for the first time. The pressure and build up is all there along with the imagery that makes any boy nervous. And of course, Liza gets in the house and imidently tries to get family's approval that she is good enough for Annie. This whole scence justifies my feeling of coverting Liza from a female to a male. I do wonder if later in the book Liza has a gender confusion issue that develops.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
Alisha,
ReplyDeleteWe discussed changing the gender of one of the characters in person in EDUC 300 yesterday, and at the point I was not as far as you. You told me that I would probably switch from Annie being the male to Liza being the male in my mind. Liza does seem to fit the male role for all of the reasons that you said. However, Annie is still the one that I view as a boy. I think that this is probably because of both my life experiences and the books I normally read.
In this book, we have Liza's point of view and only what she sees of Annie to go on. In my life, this is what I have. I have to guess at what a guy I am interested in is thinking whereas I know what I am thinking about. Additionally, when I read, I usually choose books that are written in a first person female point of view so I am used to the character who is narrating being the female while the other character, this romantic interest is male. The character that you chose to "change" fits more with the book and with rational reasons. As we read more, I may decide to switch to your view as well.
Interestingly Annie is the first to test physical contact. Annie non-traditionally lays her hand on Liza's as she points to the stars. This screams to me that she is distracting the two of them from the physical contact ever so slightly, testing the waters to see if Liza moves away. Being the first in a relationship to test physical contact is traditionally done by the male role.
ReplyDeleteInteresting thoughts and really good, specific examples, Alisha.
ReplyDeleteInteresting thoughts and really good, specific examples, Alisha.
ReplyDelete